The Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, a long-running beachfront dining and lodging destination in Cape May, New Jersey, is changing ownership after 16 years under its current operators. The announcement was made Thursday in a social media statement from the outgoing owners, who described the move as both a difficult farewell and a positive handoff to a new team. Known for its panoramic Atlantic Ocean views, elegant Georgian Revival architecture, historic character, and upscale dining, the property has long been one of Cape May’s most recognizable hospitality venues.
The new ownership group will be led by Carl and Megan Messick. The transition is expected to take place without interrupting operations at either the inn or the restaurant, according to the announcement. Carl Messick is especially familiar with the business, having spent more than 10 years as executive chef at Peter Shields Inn before leaving to open Grana BYOB. In his new role, he will oversee both the inn and the restaurant.
The outgoing owners said they devoted the past 16 years to restoring and improving the property, while also focusing on guest experience and service. They said the most meaningful part of their tenure was the hospitality they were able to provide to loyal customers and visitors. Their statement reflected gratitude for the support the business has received over the years and confidence that the property will remain true to its traditions under the new leadership.
The new owners are expected to continue the inn’s reputation for warm hospitality and the restaurant’s fine-dining experience. Both ownership teams are working together to make the transition smooth. Existing reservations, scheduled events, and gift cards will all be honored before and after the ownership change, and the business will continue accepting new bookings as usual.
Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, located at 1301 Beach Avenue, remains open seven days a week. Dinner service is available from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m., and the inn continues to operate daily. Additional information about the transition is expected in the coming weeks.
The ownership change marks a significant moment for one of Cape May’s best-known beachfront establishments, but the announcement makes clear that the business will continue operating with the same focus on guest service, dining, and historic charm that has defined it for years.
