On May 26, Part 1 of the Summer House Season 10 reunion aired on Bravo, and the episode quickly turned into a heated confrontation involving Amanda Batula, Ciara Miller, and West Wilson. The reunion centered on the timeline of Amanda’s relationship with West, with Ciara accusing Amanda of being dishonest about how close she had become with her former best friend’s ex.
Ciara said her suspicions began on January 17, when Amanda failed to respond to an invitation to meet for drinks and Ciara later saw that Amanda was at West’s apartment. Amanda said she had leaned on West after her separation from Kyle Cooke and insisted he had been supportive and checking in on her. Ciara, however, challenged that explanation and questioned why Amanda had repeatedly ignored her attempts to spend time together while spending time with West and his friends.
The situation escalated when Ciara brought out text messages in which Amanda denied being romantically involved with West. Amanda admitted she was “100%” lying at the time, but said the relationship was still “PG” when Ciara first confronted her. Other cast members also raised concerns, including Kyle, who said Amanda had turned off her location for the first time in years. Amanda defended herself by saying she simply did not want people tracking her location constantly.
Amanda and West later clarified when their relationship began. West said he made the first move, and the two confirmed their first kiss happened in February after a group brunch. Amanda also said they slept together for the first time after she and Kyle released their joint statement on March 31, though she noted it was not that same night. West tried to minimize the controversy, saying it was not a sex scandal, but the rest of the cast continued pressing them on the details.
Ciara also attacked West’s character, accusing him of being fake and suggesting he lived differently off camera than on camera. She claimed the cast was confused by Amanda and West’s relationship because West may have been involved with another woman, Meija, around the time of his appearance on Watch What Happens Live on March 24. West confirmed he had been seeing someone and that the relationship was exclusive, though he said Meija was not his girlfriend.
The reunion became more emotional when Ciara accused Amanda of knowing exactly how hurtful the situation would be and choosing to continue anyway. Ciara called Amanda weak, a snake, and said there were many other men in New York City. Amanda pushed back, saying she was no longer married, while clarifying that she and Kyle had not yet officially filed for divorce.
The episode also revisited Ciara and West’s own complicated relationship. Ciara said they continued sending flirty texts and had sleepovers even after their breakup, while West said he had tried to keep things platonic because he knew he could not be what she needed. The exchange ended on a tense emotional note, with Amanda in tears and Kyle asking Ciara to be less harsh.
Part 2 of the Summer House Season 10 reunion airs Tuesday, June 2, at 8:00 p.m. ET/PT on Bravo.
